Several everyday carry pocket knives lined up on a black table.

Choosing the Best Knife for Your Needs

A DEWALT standard utility knife cuts through a piece of drywall.

Nothing in your toolbox can make up for a quality knife. Whether it’s a utility knife, hunting knife, pocket knife, or an everyday carry knife, you need a sharp, solid blade in your arsenal. There are many things to consider when choosing the best knife, including blade type and material, weight, blade length, or non-assisted or assisted opening type. These features sometimes come down to personal preference but are also based on the primary use of the knife.

But, before worrying about the features of the blade, you need to pick a blade style. There are several styles of knives on the market, and choosing the best blade depends on how you plan to use the knife. You are a tradesperson who needs a particular knife for your profession or is just looking for an everyday carry knife for various cuts. Our knife overview will briefly explain and compare a handful of utility, snap-off, everyday carry, and fixed-blade knives.

Utility Knives

A Klein Tools retractable utility knife is used to cut a piece of drywall.

A utility knife gets its name because it has many uses for trades and hobbyists. Ease of operation combined with the razor-sharp blade makes it a vital tool for anyone who needs to make a quick cut, whether as simple as cutting open boxes or as large as slicing drywall. There are various features available in different utility blades, such as built-in blade storage, quick-blade removal, or a line/string cutting notch.

The main things you are looking for in a quality utility knife are:

  1. A comfortable, ergonomic grip.
  2. Sturdy body construction.
  3. Smooth opening.
  4. Easy access to blade storage.

There are two main styles: a retractable or folding utility knife. No matter the style, they fit easily in your pocket or tool belt for quick access, as you will need them often.

Utility Knives
Product ImageProduct NameBlade MaterialBlade LengthWeightHandle MaterialOpening TypePrice
Tajima One-Piece Premium Utility KnifeTempered Steel2 in.1 lb.SteelRetractable$$$
Stanley FatMax Fixed Folding Utility KnifeSteel2.5 in.0.32 lbs.SteelFixed$
Milwaukee FASTBACK Utility KnifeMicro Carbide Deposited Metal2 in.0.335 lbs.AluminumFlip$
Klein Tools Retractable Utility Knife440A Stainless Steel0.5 in.0.47 lbs.RubberRetractable$$
Lexon Retractable Utility KnifeBi-Metal (TiN)2.5 in.0.4 lbs.AluminumRetractable$$
Fiskars PRO Utility KnifeRazor Steel0.94 in.0.44 lbs.RubberFlip$$
Irwin ProFlip Utility KnifeBi-Metal1 in.0.5 lbs.AluminumFlip$$
DEWALT Standard Utility KnifeSteel2.5 in.0.42 lbs.SteelRetractable$
Stanley FatMax Retractable Utility KnifeSteel1 in.0.3 lbsBi-MaterialRetractable$$
Milwaukee Fixed Blade Utility KnifeSteel1.25 in.0.17 lbs.SteelRetractable$

Snap-Off Utility Knives

A Knipex snap-off utility knife cuts the tip of a tube caulk.

Snap-off utility knives work very similarly to traditional utility knives. The significant difference between the two is that snap-off utility knives feature a blade of several sections that can be broken off when the knife edge gets dull. This provides several blades out of one long blade that slides through the housing with a push trigger.

Snap-offs, such as cardboard or paper, are built more for precision cutting that does not require a lot of power. Most of these knives feature a plastic housing, but some have a metal housing for a little more heft while making cuts. Other features that set the snap-off utility knife apart from an essential utility knife are a more prolonged blade exposure, a quicker blade change out, and a safer alternative. Utility knives expose only about three-fourths of the blade, so you have a limited cutting depth. Snap-offs retract around a couple of inches if you need to make a deeper cut in foam insulation.

The snap-off feature allows a quick break of a dull section, while utility knives usually require the removal of the housing and flipping of the blade. While making that blade change, it is also safer in snap-offs as pliers are used to break the dull section, and the tool acts as a barrier to the blade.

Snap-Off Utility Knives
Product ImageProduct NameBlade MaterialBlade LengthWeightHandle MaterialPrice
Knipex Universal Knife Magnesium Faster CutMagnesium4 in.0.31 lbs.Plastic$$$
Tajima ROCK HARD Dial Lock Utility KnifeSK-1204 in.1 lb.Plastic$$
Stanley FatMax Xtreme Snap-Off KnifeSteel10.197 in.0.741 lbs.Steel$$
Milwaukee Snap-Off Utility KnifeMicro Carbide5 in.0.3 lbs.Rubber$$
Irwin Pro Touch KnifeSteel2 in.0.35 lbs.Plastic$$
DEWALT Metal Body Snap-Off KnifeSteel0.71 in.0.81 lbs.Steel$

Everyday Carry Knives

A DEWALT spring-assisted pocket knife cuts through a zip tie.

An everyday carry knife is aptly named because you always carry it, like a wallet, keys, or cell phone. Sometimes called pocketknives, they are compact, lightweight, durable, and multi-functional; they fit easily in your pocket for quick access whenever you need it during your everyday work. EDC knives are the most varied selection, with the largest selection of features, many different blade types, and blade materials.

The benefits of an everyday carry knife include convenience, utility, and emergencies. The size of an EDC blade makes it easy always to continue whenever you run into small, random cutting tasks, such as cutting tags, rope, or open packages. Most feature a pocket clip, so you do not have to dig through your pocket or tool belt. Also, they are a suitable alternative to carrying around large, cumbersome hunting knives while camping. In an emergency, they can be the thing that saves your life; for example, they can easily cut through a seat belt after a car accident.

Everyday Carry Knives
Product ImageProduct NameBlade TypeBlade MaterialBlade LengthWeightHandle MaterialSpring Assisted OpenPrice
Klein Tools Electrician's Pocket KnifeDrop PointStainless Steel3 in.0.28 lbs.AluminumNo$
Crescent Harpoon Blade Pocket KnifeHarpoonD2 Steel3.25 in.0.345 lbs.AluminumNo$$
DEWALT Spring Assist Pocket KnifeDrop PointStainless Steel3.2 in.0.398 lbs.NylonYes$
Milwaukee FASTBACK Spring Assisted Folding KnifeTantoStainless Steel3 in.0.24 lbs.PlasticYes$
Gearwrench Spring Assisted Folding Pocket KnifeDrop PointStainless Steel3.06 in.0.35 lbs.MetalYes$
Gerber Shark Belly Pocket KnifeModern Drop Point420HC steel3.25 in.0.33 lbs.Glass-Filled NylonNo$$
Klein Tools Tanto Lockback KnifeTantoStainless Steel2.5 in.0.3 lbs.AluminumNo$$$$
DEWALT Carbon Fiber Pocket KnifeDrop PointCarbon3.5 in.0.36 lbs.Carbon FiberNo$$$
Milwaukee FASTBACK Blunt Tip Hawkbill Folding KnifeHawkbillStainless Steel2.45 in.0.54 lbs.PlasticNo$
Klein Tools Lightweight Lockback KnifeSheepsfootStainless Steel2.5 in.0.094 lbs.AluminumNo$$$$

Fixed Blade Knives

A Milwaukee tradesman fixed blade knife is used to cut through insulation.

Fixed blade knives are the stronger counterparts to a foldable everyday carry knife. They are either full tang or partial tang, meaning they extend through the entire handle or partially, which gives them added durability and strength. Because of their design, fixed-blade knives are ideal for stricter cutting applications such as field dressing or other challenging camping tasks, where an EDC knife cannot provide the same amount of leverage.

A fixed-blade knife’s straight, simple construction makes it more durable as it is easier to clean and withstand the elements better. The durability of these blades also gives them a longer life span, so you do not have to worry about replacement for many years. There are some disadvantages to fixed-blade knives, though. Their generous size makes them more challenging to carry with you, so you must know you will use the blade and remember to bring it.

Fixed Blade Knives
Product ImageProduct NameBlade MaterialBlade LengthWeightHandle MaterialBlade TypePrice
Milwaukee Tradesman Fixed Blade Knife
Stainless Steel4 in.0.5 lbs.NylonDrop point$
Crescent Serrated Duct KnifeStainless Steel6 in.0.53 lbs.RubberDouble-Edged$$
Milwaukee Lineman's Underground KnifeStainless Steel1.75 in.0.12 lbs.NylonSheepsfoot$$
Irwin Linoleum KnifeSteel4.8 in.0.7 lbs. WoodHawkbill$
Milwaukee HARDLINE Fixed Blade KnifeAUS-8 Steel5 in.0.7 lbs.Nylon, RubberDrop Point$$$$$
Stanley Linoleum Flooring Knife (XRU18Z)Steel3 in.0.21 lbs.WoodHawkbill$

Shop even more utility knives and knife types from some of the top brands in the industry, including Milwaukee Tool, DEWALT, Irwin, GEARWRENCH, Crescent Tools, Stanley, Lenox, Klein Tools, and so much more at AcmeTools.com! We’re your premier authorized hand-cutting tool dealer.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.